UPS and FedEx Alternatives: The Power of Carrier and Courier Diversity in An Unpredictable World

The urgency for carrier and courier diversity has risen sharply in a world marked by escalating uncertainties. Even though a potential supply chain disaster was averted following the last-minute labor agreement between the Teamsters and UPS, such disruptions and their potentially catastrophic consequences rip the band-aid off single-carrier dependency risks and expose the desperate need to explore FedEx and UPS alternatives. 

Why? Had this strike gone through, it would have prolonged delivery times, disrupted supply chains, inflated shipping costs and inflicted a multibillion-dollar dent in the U.S. economy. Yet despite these clear drawbacks of single-carrier dependence, many shippers are still surprisingly exposed to such risk. This UPS crisis won’t be the last labor dispute or disruption ever to threaten the supply chain. So it begs the question: Are you prepared?   

The Risks of Single-Sourcing Carriers and Couriers

The risks of single-carrier dependency and the need for carrier diversity are apparent, with supply chains continually threatened by labor disputes and other disruptions. Here’s how over-relying on one carrier can lead to operational challenges and impact the customer experience:

The Pitfalls of Single-Carrier Dependence

Reliance on a single carrier or courier introduces numerous challenges that can disrupt service and negatively impact the customer experience. These include: 

  • Service Interruptions: Major disruptions in delivery schedules can arise if a carrier confronts issues like a strike, technical problems or logistical complications.  
  • Restricted Geographic Coverage: Single carriers may only provide comprehensive coverage across some regions, possibly leading to extended delivery times or failure to deliver in certain areas.
  • Unpredictable Price Shifts: A single carrier, devoid of competitive pressures, holds the power to escalate prices or alter its pricing structure, potentially increasing shipping costs.
  • Limited Operational Flexibility: Businesses might find themselves bending to the carrier’s schedules and procedures due to the lack of alternatives, reducing their operational freedom.
  • Capacity Constraints: Single carriers may struggle to handle all shipments during peak periods like the holiday season, which can cause significant delays.
  • Concentrated Risk: Placing the entire shipping operation under one carrier increases the company’s vulnerability if the carrier encounters substantial problems.
  • Impaired Customer Experience: Delayed deliveries, increased costs passed onto the customer and a shortage of delivery options can all result from these issues. Over time, customer trust and satisfaction can erode, damaging the brand’s reputation.

The Ticking Time Bomb: The Consequences of a Labor Strike and Single-Sourcing

Recall the UPS strike of 1997 — the nation’s largest package delivery company staggered to a slow crawl, leaving FedEx and the postal service hustling to fill the void. The recent threat of a UPS strike involving 340,000 workers underlines the profound risks of relying on a single carrier in today’s volatile supply chain. Had it not been averted, a 10-day strike, as estimated by Anderson Economic Group, could have wrought seismic shockwaves through the U.S. economy, resulting in a staggering $7 billion fallout

Following such a strike in today’s supply chain, businesses could grapple with abrupt delivery disruptions and a frantic hunt for viable UPS alternatives. The consequent spike in demand for other carriers may inflate costs, with service quality in the crosshairs. Moreover, as these disruptions ripple out, they could fracture customer satisfaction, tarnish business reputations, and initiate a downward financial spiral characterized by lost sales, rising costs and potential future losses.

At the same time, Yellow’s halt of operations and bankruptcy further underscore the inherent risks of relying on a single carrier, driving home the necessity for diversification. This disturbing situation further underscores the inherent risks of relying on a single carrier, driving home the necessity for diversification.

The Benefits of Carrier and Courier Diversity

A diversified approach to carriers and couriers is paramount in the face of labor disputes and other headwinds. This strategy is more than just an operational decision; it ensures business continuity, competitive pricing and service quality.

Resilience via Diversification

Adopting a multi-carrier strategy bolsters your delivery network’s resilience. Incorporating alternatives to FedEx and UPS creates a protective shield, mitigating risks and ensuring operational stability. Each carrier’s unique strength broadens your geographic reach, offering improved coverage.

Additionally, these diverse carriers collectively manage the surge in peak demand periods, negating capacity constraints. Even if one stumbles, another can step up to guarantee uninterrupted service and business continuity.

Service, Pricing, Flexibility: The Triple Crown of Carrier Diversity

Carrier diversity is a gateway to a suite of unique strengths, offering an enhanced quality of service. This diversity leverages carriers’ individual strengths, whether on-time delivery, handling delicate items or providing superior customer service. By harnessing carrier diversity, businesses can orchestrate a perfect blend of service improvement, competitive pricing and flexible solutions, all tailored to meet diverse customer needs.

In addition, the competition among multiple carriers catalyzes competitive pricing and more flexible delivery options. Simultaneously, this competition equips businesses with negotiation leverage and empowers them to secure the most favorable service terms.

Simplifying Complexity: The Magic of Multi-Carrier Shipping Platforms

With multi-carrier shipping platforms, taking advantage of the wide range of carriers and couriers available has never been easier. These advanced software solutions effortlessly streamline operations, providing an efficient management structure that navigates the complexities of multiple shipping functions.

These platforms act as personal shipping advisors, providing real-time carrier rate comparisons and automated selections based on cost, speed and coverage. With integrated tracking across all carriers and insightful data aggregation, they empower ongoing optimization of shipping operations.

The Role of Last Mile or OmniPoint Delivery/Multi-Carrier Shipping Platform Technology

The role of last mile delivery/multi-carrier shipping platform technology holds transformative potential for managing diverse carrier networks. Let’s dive into these compelling capabilities and their profound benefits.

Enhancing Delivery Management

Last mile delivery/multi-carrier shipping platform technology effectively manages a network of diverse carriers and couriers. The beauty of this technology lies in its ability to centralize management and automate carrier selection while alleviating administrative pressures.

These platforms offer full transparency across all shipments by providing real-time visibility. Their capacity to integrate seamlessly with other business systems ensures data fluidity. Moreover, they shine in scalability, readily expanding to incorporate new carriers or shipping options as your business evolves.

The Compelling Benefits of Last Mile and Multi-Carrier Platforms

The power of last mile or omnipoint delivery/multi-carrier shipping platform technology lies in its ability to transform business operations significantly. These advanced tools elevate efficiency, streamlining carrier selection and management while improving service quality and delivery speed.

The cherry on top? These platforms are a strategic tool for cost savings, providing the flexibility to choose the most cost-effective carriers. Enhanced operational adaptability allows businesses to adjust their carrier mix seamlessly as needs evolve. Data-driven insights equip businesses with invaluable knowledge to optimize their shipping operations.

The OneRail Solution

OneRail combines diverse carrier options with cutting-edge logistics tech to transform last mile delivery for retailers. Let’s explore how OneRail’s dynamic network and innovative platform can serve as a viable FedEx or UPS alternative amid supply chain disruptions.

Embracing Diversity with OneRail’s Expansive Network

OneRail and its 99% on-time delivery rate is the linchpin in last mile delivery, bridging an immense network of over 12 million drivers, 600 courier entities, and 65+ logistics companies across 350 major U.S. cities. This vast and integrated network offers shippers the unique advantage of elastic capacity, assuring the availability of optimal delivery resources at any time. The inclusion of preferred couriers within the network also ensures they have the opportunity to grow and diversify their service offerings.

Shifting the focus to the operational front, OneRail’s lightning-fast OmniPoint Platform expertly matches delivery jobs with the most reliable couriers at predetermined stable prices. The platform provides swift connectivity to many fleet options as a productive tool for managing fulfillment capacity and tackling location coverage issues. Moreover, the platform embodies efficiency by enabling complete courier management from a single dashboard.

OneRail’s Unmatched Features and Benefits for Carrier Diversity 

OneRail is leading the charge in last mile delivery with its pioneering software platform, automating crucial aspects of delivery order management. This automation game-changer frees businesses from manual labor and efficiently handles important delivery details — mastering the complexities of multimodal networks by assigning shipments to the most suitable couriers, making every delivery cost-efficient. 

OneRail excels in its automated rate shopping feature, navigating its expansive network to secure the best rates, consequently accelerating delivery speed while cutting costs. It goes beyond offering real-time tracking, alerting businesses to potential risks. At the same time, OneRail’s dedicated Exceptions Assist™ team proactively tackles delivery delays. 

Seizing the Power of Carrier Diversity: OneRail As Your FedEx and UPS Alternative

Carrier diversity has emerged as a critical buffer against potential disruptions. By diversifying courier options, businesses can mitigate risks and secure on-time deliveries, irrespective of individual interruptions. Platforms such as OneRail enable this versatility, propelling businesses into a realm of seamless delivery management.

OneRail stands out as a UPS and FedEx alternative, providing end-to-end visibility and matching deliveries to the most suitable couriers at pre-established rates —  and adding value and streamlining supply chain connectivity by expertly managing fleet assets on behalf of businesses.  

Adopting a multi-carrier approach can elevate delivery networks and enhance customer service. Platforms like OneRail empower businesses to take full advantage of a comprehensive network of carriers, select their ideal match and reap the manifold rewards: lower costs, expedited delivery times and an elevated customer experience. See for yourself and schedule a demo today.

Get a PDF copy of this article for printing or sharing here.

See how OneRail can
simplify your supply chain.

Let's Talk


OmniPoint™ Platform

Our data-driven visibility solution is architected on the trusted Microsoft Azure platform.

Schedule a Demo

See OneRail in action, and take the first step toward a connected supply chain.



Our team of technologists optimizes your last mile with customized solutions for a quick time-to-value.

Get Started

Dig into the details with a no-risk Value Analysis.



The world’s largest brands across major industries rely on our adaptable, scalable delivery solution.

TMS White Paper

Learn what’s missing from your TMS, and what customers are looking for in last mile delivery.

Let's Talk